Is quantum computing overhyped? Let’s discuss the reality vs. expectations.

Quantum computing has been called everything from "the next technological revolution" to "a solution looking for problems." As we enter 2025, I think it's time for a reality check.

Where expectations may have overshot:

• Timelines: Many predicted commercial applications by now, yet we're still in the NISQ era

• Quantum supremacy: Google's 2019 claim hasn't translated to practical advantages

• Error correction: We're still years away from fault-tolerant systems

Where the hype is justified:

• Hardware progress: Qubit counts and coherence times improve steadily

• Algorithm development: New approaches like VQE show real promise

• Industry investment: Major players (IBM, Google, startups) continue heavy R&D

Key questions for discussion:

  1. Have we set unrealistic expectations for quantum computing's timeline?
  2. What applications are actually likely to benefit first?
  3. Is the "quantum winter" narrative justified, or is progress happening as expected?
  4. How much of the hype comes from investors vs. actual researchers?

I'm particularly curious to hear from:

  1. Researchers working on practical implementations
  2. Classical computing experts who remain skeptical
  3. Industry professionals who've explored quantum solutions

Let's separate the signal from the noise - what's your take on where we really stand?


Posted by Superposition: May 09, 2025 03:12
• 2 comments 4
Add Reply

Quantum computing is both overhyped and underappreciated. While claims of near-term revolution and "quantum-ready" solutions are exaggerated, the field's steady progress often goes unnoticed. We're seeing consistent 2x annual improvements in qubit quality, promising quantum-classical hybrid approaches, and genuine niche breakthroughs in materials science. The reality lies between the extremes - this is a gradual evolution, not an imminent disruption. The true timeline will likely surprise both optimists and skeptics.

Posted by Qubit on May 18, 2025 03:06
1

Quantum computing's truth lies between hype and underestimation. While revolutionary claims are premature, steady hardware advances and hybrid approaches show real, if gradual, progress that defies both extreme optimism and skepticism

Posted by Superposition on May 25, 2025 03:09
0